Standpoint theory, a feminist theoretical perspective that argues that knowledge stems from social position. The perspective denies that traditional science is objective and suggests that research and theory has ignored and marginalized women and feminist ways of thinking. But how do we actually go about integrating a feminist. This paper explores the applicability of standpoint theory within and outside of feminism by examining a journal debate in signs about standpoint theory from 1997. The logic of feminist standpoint theory for social work research. All formulations of standpoint theory contend that a standpoint arises when an individual recognizes and challenges cultural values and power relations that contribute to subordination or oppression of particular groups. Key concepts hegemonic masculinity patriarchal dividend. It is both a theory of knowledge building and a method of doing researchan approach to knowledge construction and a call to political action. Particularly among younger feminist theorists, feminist standpoint theory is frequently regarded as a quaint relic of feminisms less sophisticated past. Feminist standpoint theory claims that the standpoint of women has an epistemic advantage over phenomena in which gender is implicated, relative to theories that make sexist or androcentric assumptions. Standpoint theory is a broad categorization that includes somewhat diverse theories ranging from hartsocks 1983 feminist historical. Feminist standpoint theory pdf ala award winning books 2015, to ground the transformation arguments, the article draws on a feminist standpoint theory.
Conceiving feminist standpoint theory as an analytical tool rather than as an epistemological doctrine, this article investigates the merits of this methodological approach for fostering an. Feminist standpoint theory states a privilege in gender relations, various feminist standpoint theories are based on the statement about the epistemic privilege in different feministic situations. Feminist standpoint theory raises a central and unavoidable question for feminist theory. This paper compares two very different, even seemingly incommensurate critical responses to certain antidemocratic, antijustice, and possibly antilife features of classic epistemology, political theory, and metaphysics.
In this paper i continue to explore the insights of feminist standpoint theory by discussing hardings. Rosemarie tong finding her own voice and sharing with us the voices of other africanamerican women, collins brilliantly explicates our unique standpoint. Feminist standpoint epistemology requires the fusion of knowledge and practice. Pdf feminist standpoint theory, chapter 8 of philosophy. There is a large variety of positions among feminists concerning these issues, starting from. This phrase pulls together disparate thinkers and trends in. The result was a new theory, now recognized as standpoint theory, which caused heated debate and radically altered the way research is conducted. Standpoint feminism and discourse poststructuralist theorist critique standpoint theory as a, knowledge project that correctly produced knowledge will lead to the adoption of the best political strategies. Feminist epistemology and philosophy of science stanford. Standpoint theory seeks to develop a particular feminist epistemology, that values the experiences of women and minorities as a source for knowledge. The theory emerged from the marxist argument that people from an. While the origins of standpoint theory lie in marxs view of class oppression, feminist philosophy popularized and developed standpoint theory in the 1970s and 1980s.
One can understand spontaneous feminist empiricism and feminist standpoint theory to be making competing arguments on two topics scientific method and historyin order to explain in their different ways the causes of sexist and androcentric results of scientific re search. Sandra harding and nancy hartsock developed the stand point theory through the book the feminist stand point. The idea is that a womans role in society, often an oppressed one, gives her a unique perspective. Feminist standpoint theory is one of the types of critical theory, their main intention is to improve their situation. Is standpoint theory a resource for feminist epistemology. Dorothy smith is a canadian sociologist best known for her critiques of male bias within social theory and for the development of institutional ethnography. Of all published articles, the following were the most read within the past 12 months. One should read this book in order to understand the standpoint theory and especially its epistemology. The feminist standpoint theory reader is the first anthology to collect the most important essays on the subject. Contemporary standpoint feminist theory perceives that it is a relational standpoint, rather than arising inevitably from the experience of women 8 see difference feminism. As an oppressed group, women have been unable to achieve their potential, receive rewards, or gain full participation in society. Logic of feminist standpoint theory for social work. Rather, there have been evolutions of the different frameworks under the broad heading of feminist theory since the late 1700s.
Situating feminist standpoint theory scholarship at uwindsor. First, science communicators should aim to understand the. This article presents feminist standpoint theory as an epistemology to move social work research and practice toward a synthesis of relevance and rigor. Contemporary standpoint theory often focuses on the social positions such as gender, race, class, culture, and economic status. Feminist standpoint theory by nasrullah mambrol on november 12, 2018 0. Now she argued in defence of situated knowledges that. There is no original or primary gender a drag imitates, but gender is a kind of. Feminist standpoint theory naples major reference works. Feminist standpoint theory on making strange project muse. Towards an australian indigenous womens standpoint theory. Feminist standpoint theory literary theory and criticism.
It is unusual to find these two perspectives in dialogue. The history, the ontology and epistemology of the standpoint theory are well explained in a number of articles. Feminist standpoint theory was initially formulated in the context of marxist politics. The feminist standpoint theory reader download ebook pdf. Using examples, explain feminist standpoint theory. The standpoint theory focuses on gender perception focusing on to the feminist viewpoints. As haraway puts the point from the perspective of the former position the sexual division of labour. Central to the initial impulse of feminist standpoint theory was challenging forms of scientific neutrality and objectivity that presupposed a generalized knower. Crasnow and others published feminist standpoint theory find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. Standpoint theory emerged in the 1970s and 1980s as a feminist critical theory about relations between the production of knowledge and. Harding 2003 has brought together the most influential essays on feminist standpoint theory to demonstrate the power and utility of standpoint theory for feminist praxis. Feminist standpoint epistemology is characterized by two related claims.
How do we justify the truth of the feminist claim that women have been and are oppressed. Standpoint theory as a methodology for the study of power. The responses from hartsock 1997a, harding 1997, and smith 1997, published in the same issue were very critical of hekmans 1997 ideas. Feminist epistemology and the politics of knowledge. More recently, a type of feminist social theory called standpoint epistemology reflects the influence of marxs social and economic determinism. Standpoint theory an overview sciencedirect topics.
Empiricists, on this analysis, sought to develop a method of evidencegathering that would be cleansed of androcentrism, paying attention to. Pdf on jan 1, 2007, abigail t brooks and others published feminist standpoint epistemology. Her work is a cornerstone of feminist social theory, and has been highly influential to second and thirdwave feminist thought and politics. Adopted from elements of marxist theory, feminist standpoint theory also represents one of the more thorough attempts to ground epistemology and, correspondingly, a view of knowers in a social theory. Feminist standpoint theory feminist standpoint theory is a specific formulation of the broader standpoint theory. The theory places the life experiences of marginalized groups at the center of the research project. Women had been given many rights by the time this theory had been developed, including the right to vote, but the terminology and attitude by. It offers two ways in which feminist standpoints can help in both research and practice. Click download or read online button to get the feminist standpoint theory reader book now. Feminist standpoint theory is an approach to research that is more consonant with the professional values and goals of social work.
The debate took place at a crucial point of transition between second and thirdwave feminism. The feminist standpoint theory has roots in marxism and critiques patriarchal societies. Pdf conceiving feminist standpoint theory as an analytical tool rather than as an epistemological doctrine, this article investigates the merits of. Hartsock the feminist standpoint pdf feminist standpoint theory revisited. Women have something valuable to contribute to every aspect of the world. Feminist standpoint theory, which borrows a lot from hegels theories, postulates that those in marginalized in social or political power relations, will rise to challenge the social order within which they find themselves. Feminism is the doctrine advocating social, political, and economic rights for. To document and define this ambiguity of oppressed groups, feminist standpoint theory scholars, borrowing from dubois 1996 1903, came up with the notion of double vision brooks 2007. Feminist standpoint theory, then, makes a contribution to epistemology, within a number of disciplinessuch as dorothy smith, nancy hartsock, hilary rose. Feminist standpoint theory, chapter 8 of philosophy of social science. Feminist therapy is not only personal but, like feminism, political in nature. Feminist standpoint theory as analytical tool article pdf available in women s studies international forum january 1999 with 1,860 reads how we measure reads. Feminist social epistemology stanford encyclopedia of. The feminist standpoint theory was initially developed when feminism was a small, but growing movement within industrialized civilizations.
Feminist standpoint theory internet encyclopedia of. Developing ground for a specifically feminist historical materialism. Building knowledge and empowerment through womens lived experience find, read and cite all the. The theory bases itself on the idea that women are utterly oppressed.
Standpoint theory is dead, long live standpoint theory. Sex, and power changed the landscape of feminist theo. A feminist standpoint therefore is essential to examining the systemic oppressions in society that devalue womens knowledge. The feminist standpoint theory reader centre for the study of. Black feminist thought the flame by unite youth dublin. Feminist standpoint theorists make three principal claims. Feminist standpoint theory has done the most to articulate the importance of perspectival differences stemming from social location. Several developments in the late 1980s have led to this declining influence. Feminist standpoint theory request pdf researchgate. Several strands in feminist theory and practice which show clearly the gradual positioning of feminist knowledge are sometimes grouped under the umbrella term feminist standpoint theory. Feminist standpoint theory is a broad categorization that includes somewhat diverse theories ranging from hartsocks feminist historical materialist perspective, to haraways analysis of situated knowledges, collins black feminist thought, sandovals explication of third world feminists differential oppositional consciousness, and smiths everyday world sociology for women. Standpoint theorists are found in a wide variety of disciplines and continue to raise important questions about the way power influences knowledge in a variety of fields. It then directs the view of the researcher toward the social structures that shape the lives of the group members. It focuses on diversity, gender issues and sexism, and is committed to both individual and social change.
1007 142 616 575 873 416 1039 866 711 629 923 1385 1092 828 1396 140 1561 1677 241 636 431 36 234 550 1375 1607 1169 1513 1081 484 1166 145 913 200 731 1483 1073 484 236 985 1270 90 1436